NFL Kicks of the Week, Week 9: Spencer Shrader Ties It From 59
Spencer Shrader lined up from 59 yards with the Colts down 20-17 to Dallas and just under six minutes left, and tied it. Our model gave the kick a 57.5% chance, and it is the Kick of the Week, even though the Cowboys won 27-23 with a touchdown in the final 1:08. It was also the best week of the season for NFL kickers as a group: 64 of 71, 90.1%.
Kick of the Week: Spencer Shrader, 59 yards, Cowboys at Colts
We couldn't find a YouTube clip of this kick from the league or either team. The NFL has it on its own site: Shrader's 59-yard FG ties Cowboys-Colts game.
Dallas led 17-7 at halftime at Lucas Oil Stadium, and Ashton Dulin's 55-yard touchdown late in the third quarter cut it to 20-17. With 5:56 left in the fourth, Spencer Shrader came on from 59. Luke Rhodes snapped, Rigoberto Sanchez held, and the kick tied the game at 20. Then the game swung on two 50-yarders. Brandon Aubrey missed his wide left with 3:30 to go, a kick that would have put Dallas back in front. Shrader made his, and the Indianapolis Colts led 23-20 with 1:37 left, their first lead since the first quarter. Dallas answered with a 65-yard drive in 29 seconds, and Javonte Williams scored from a yard out with 1:08 to play. It was Indianapolis's fifth straight loss.
From 58 to 60 yards, NFL kickers made 54 of 92 tries over the last five seasons, 58.7%, and our model put this one at 57.5%. The distance and the fourth-quarter moment together gave it a Kick Score of 9.35. It is Shrader's longest make of the season. He is 22 of 24 this year, 8 of 9 from 50 or more and 5 of 6 from 55 or more, and he led the week in MAKE.
Runner-up: Cairo Santos, 38 yards, Chicago Bears
Tampa Bay tied the game at 24 with 2:51 left after a Chicago fumble. With about a minute to go, Caleb Williams found Colston Loveland for 38 yards to the Tampa Bay 16, then knelt twice to put the ball on the right hash, where Cairo Santos wanted it. Scott Daly snapped, Tory Taylor held, and Santos made the 38-yarder as time expired for a 27-24 win at Soldier Field. "I had to have my teammates' backs," he told the Sun-Times. The kick was a 90% chance on our model; it is here for the moment. The Chicago Bears won despite five turnovers and are 7-2. Santos is 15 of 19 this season.
Third: Andre Szmyt, 51 yards, Cleveland Browns
The Saints scored a touchdown with 58 seconds left to go up 16-13 at the Caesars Superdome. Cleveland got a 30-yard catch from Jerry Jeudy, and Andre Szmyt tied it from 51 with 8 seconds left, sending the game to overtime. Rex Sunahara snapped and Corey Bojorquez held. Kickers made 73.5% from 50 to 52 yards over the last five seasons. The Cleveland Browns lost 23-22 when New Orleans stopped their two-point try after a touchdown in overtime. Szmyt was 3 for 3 and is 19 of 21 this season, 3 for 3 from 50 or more.
Fourth: Charlie Smyth, 48 yards, New Orleans Saints
Charlie Smyth missed a 52-yarder wide right in the first quarter of the same game. He made his next three, the last a 48-yarder that broke a 6-6 tie with 5:38 left in regulation. Zach Wood snapped and Ryan Wright held. Kickers made 74.7% from 47 to 49 yards over the last five seasons. The New Orleans Saints won 23-22 in overtime, their first home win of the season.
Fifth: Evan McPherson, 57 yards, Cincinnati Bengals
Evan McPherson hit a 57-yarder in the final seconds of the first half at the Santiago Bernabeu in Madrid, under a closed roof, to put Cincinnati up 24-10 at the break. From 56 to 58 yards, kickers made 62.1% over the last five seasons, and our model put this one at 66%. William Wagner snapped and Ryan Rehkow held. He added a 43-yarder in the fourth quarter, and the Cincinnati Bengals beat Atlanta 34-17 for their fourth straight win. McPherson has made all 12 of his field goals this season, 6 for 6 from 50 or more and 4 for 4 from 55 or more.
The one that got away
No kick this week fit our heartbreaker rule: a fourth-quarter or overtime miss by a team that went on to lose, one that would have tied the game or taken the lead. The closest was in the Kick of the Week game. Brandon Aubrey's 50-yarder with the score tied at 20 and 3:30 left went wide left, and Shrader's 50 on the next possession put Indianapolis ahead. Dallas still won.
The week in numbers
| Stat | This week |
|---|---|
| Field goals made | 64 of 71 (90.1%) |
| Expected makes for those kicks | 60.7 |
| 50+ yards | 14 of 18 |
| 55+ yards | 3 of 3 |
| Under 40 yards | 29 of 31 |
| Walk-off field goals | 1 |
| Longest make | 59 yards, Spencer Shrader (Indianapolis Colts) |
| MAKE leader for the week | Spencer Shrader (Indianapolis Colts), 3-3, MAKE +0.88 |
Kickers made 3.3 more field goals than the model expected, and all three tries of 55 yards or more were good.
How we pick the Kicks of the Week
Every made field goal gets a Kick Score: how unlikely it was (one minus the make chance, times 10), plus 0.15 for each yard past 45, plus the moment: 8 for a walk-off winner, 4 for a go-ahead kick, 3 for a tying kick, 1 for any other fourth-quarter or overtime kick in a one-score game. The moment counts in full on kicks with a make chance of 60% or less and shrinks on chip shots, so a long bomb can outrank a short winner. Make chances come from the same distance and conditions model behind the MAKE Rankings. A kicker can appear at most twice. Last week: NFL Kicks of the Week, Week 8: Chad Ryland Wins It in Overtime After a Missed PAT.
Data: nflverse play-by-play (CC BY 4.0); make chances, Kick Scores and MAKE by FKS.