| 2026 (in progress) | Connor Hawkins 8-10 FG | Joe McGuire 39.5 net | Dalton Riggs 9 snaps | Marcello Diomede 48 KO
Cooper Peterson 2 KO |
| 2025 | Jayden Fielding 16-19 FG | Joe McGuire 40.0 net
Nick McLarty 45.0 net | John Ferlmann 9 snaps | Jayden Fielding 84 KO
Jackson Courville 4 KO |
| 2024 | Jayden Fielding 9-12 FG | Joe McGuire 40.6 net
Nick McLarty 32.5 net | — | Jayden Fielding 64 KO
D.Stevens 2 KO |
| 2023 | Jayden Fielding 15-18 FG | Jesse Mirco 40.3 net | — | Jayden Fielding 75 KO
Parker Lewis 2 KO |
| 2022 | Noah Ruggles 15-17 FG | Jesse Mirco 41.5 net
Michael O'Shaughnessy 21.0 net | — | Jayden Fielding 97 KO |
| 2021 | Noah Ruggles 18-19 FG | Jesse Mirco 41.5 net | — | Noah Ruggles 92 KO
Dominic DiMaccio 8 KO |
| 2020 | Blake Haubeil 5-7 FG
Dominic DiMaccio 1-2 FG | Drue Chrisman 42.8 net
Zach Hoover 39.3 net | — | Dominic DiMaccio 32 KO
Blake Haubeil 15 KO |
| 2019 | Blake Haubeil 10-12 FG | Drue Chrisman 39.7 net | — | Blake Haubeil 105 KO
Dominic DiMaccio 2 KO |
| 2018 | Blake Haubeil 9-11 FG
Sean Nuernberger 3-5 FG | Drue Chrisman 42.6 net | — | Blake Haubeil 96 KO |
| 2017 | Sean Nuernberger 16-20 FG | Drue Chrisman 41.4 net | — | Blake Haubeil 82 KO
Sean Nuernberger 15 KO |
| 2016 | Tyler Durbin 17-19 FG
Grant Haley 0-1 FG | Cameron Johnston 43.4 net | — | Tyler Durbin 90 KO |
| 2015 | Jack Willoughby 7-11 FG
Sean Nuernberger 0-1 FG | Cameron Johnston 40.8 net | — | Jack Willoughby 76 KO |
| 2014 | Sean Nuernberger 11-18 FG | Cameron Johnston 41.3 net | — | Kyle Clinton 100 KO |
| 2013 | Drew Basil 9-10 FG | Cameron Johnston 42.8 net
Braxton Miller pass incomplete. Cameron Johnston 34.0 net | — | Drew Basil 90 KO
Kyle Clinton 3 KO |
| 2012 | Drew Basil 8-10 FG | Ben Buchanan 39.0 net | — | Drew Basil 69 KO
Kyle Clinton 2 KO |
| 2011 | Drew Basil 15-17 FG | Ben Buchanan 40.2 net | — | Drew Basil 57 KO
Ben Buchanan 1 KO |
