| 2026 (in progress) | Ethan Head 7-12 FG | Evan Crenshaw 41.0 net | Colton Walls 10 snaps
Kendall Roseberry 2 snaps | Ethan Head 31 KO |
| 2025 | Scott Taylor Renfroe 9-13 FG
Paddy McAteer 1-2 FG | Evan Crenshaw 41.7 net | Colton Walls 5 snaps | Paddy McAteer 60 KO |
| 2024 | Scott Taylor Renfroe 11-13 FG | Robert Cole 35.3 net
Evan Crenshaw 12.0 net | — | Paddy McAteer 60 KO
Scott Taylor Renfroe 2 KO |
| 2023 | Scott Taylor Renfroe 18-22 FG | Robert Cole 40.2 net
Gunnar Watson 11.0 net | — | Zach Long 76 KO
Scott Taylor Renfroe 3 KO |
| 2022 | Brooks Buce 16-18 FG | Mike Rivers 38.8 net | — | Zach Long 35 KO
Brooks Buce 26 KO |
| 2021 | Brooks Buce 8-9 FG | Luke Magliozzi 37.4 net | — | Brooks Buce 31 KO
Kyle Coale 22 KO |
| 2020 | Evan Legassey 13-21 FG | Jack Martin 46.2 net
Kyle Coale 36.8 net | — | Jack Martin 48 KO
Evan Legassey 6 KO |
| 2019 | Tyler Sumpter 14-18 FG | Tyler Sumpter 39.1 net
Evan Legassey 35.0 net | — | Jack Martin 68 KO
Evan Legassey 5 KO |
| 2018 | Tyler Sumpter 18-24 FG | Tyler Sumpter 41.9 net
Evan Legassey 36.0 net | — | Bratcher Underwood 66 KO
Evan Legassey 4 KO |
| 2017 | Tyler Sumpter 7-9 FG
Evan Legassey 1-5 FG | Tyler Sumpter 36.0 net | — | Bratcher Underwood 57 KO
Tyler Sumpter 1 KO |
| 2016 | Ryan Kay 18-21 FG | Ryan Kay 38.9 net | — | Bratcher Underwood 63 KO |
| 2015 | Jed Solomon 15-19 FG
Ryan Kay 1-2 FG | Ryan Kay 37.0 net | — | Jed Solomon 61 KO
Bratcher Underwood 2 KO |
| 2014 | Ryan Kay 10-14 FG | Ryan Kay 36.1 net | — | Jed Solomon 52 KO |
| 2013 | Will Scott 11-15 FG | Will Scott 43.1 net
Ryan Kay 37.7 net | — | Jed Solomon 57 KO
Will Scott 12 KO |
| 2012 | Will Scott 17-21 FG | Will Scott 40.1 net | — | Jed Solomon 39 KO
Will Scott 27 KO |
| 2011 | Michael Taylor 8-13 FG | Will Goggans 38.7 net
Michael Taylor 28.0 net | — | Michael Taylor 38 KO
Spencer Martin 2 KO |
