| 2026 (in progress) | Sam Keltner 13-13 FG | Lachie Pozzobon 39.9 net | Caden Yates 9 snaps
Nolan Akins 4 snaps | Joseph Kim 45 KO |
| 2025 | Logan Ward 15-20 FG | Wes Pahl 42.6 net
Chase Barry 52.0 net | Aidan Davenport 6 snaps | Logan Ward 23 KO
Wes Pahl 20 KO |
| 2024 | Logan Ward 12-17 FG | Hudson Kaak 40.9 net
Wes Pahl 42.0 net | — | Wes Pahl 33 KO
Logan Ward 31 KO |
| 2023 | Alex Hale 26-32 FG | Hudson Kaak 40.5 net
Wes Pahl 40.3 net | — | Logan Ward 78 KO |
| 2022 | Tanner Brown 21-22 FG | Tom Hutton 36.3 net
Logan Ward 40.5 net | — | Logan Ward 35 KO
Tanner Brown 21 KO |
| 2021 | Tanner Brown 14-17 FG
Alex Hale 3-6 FG | Tom Hutton 40.4 net
G.Kell 61.0 net | — | Tanner Brown 71 KO
Brady Pohl 6 KO |
| 2020 | Alex Hale 14-15 FG
Brady Pohl 3-6 FG | Tom Hutton 39.2 net
Jake McClure 28.3 net | — | Jake McClure 45 KO
Alex Hale 10 KO |
| 2019 | Matt Ammendola 20-24 FG | Tom Hutton 37.7 net
Jake McClure 41.0 net | — | Jake McClure 72 KO
Alex Hale 5 KO |
| 2018 | Matt Ammendola 15-21 FG | Zach Sinor 40.5 net
Matt Hockett 39.7 net | — | Jake McClure 81 KO
Matt Hockett 5 KO |
| 2017 | Matt Ammendola 20-26 FG | Zach Sinor 38.1 net
Matt Hockett 49.0 net | — | Matt Ammendola 98 KO
Matt Hockett 5 KO |
| 2016 | Ben Grogan 18-23 FG
Matt Ammendola 1-1 FG | Zach Sinor 40.4 net | — | Matt Ammendola 76 KO
Zach Sinor 7 KO |
| 2015 | Ben Grogan 14-18 FG
Matt Hockett 0-1 FG | Zach Sinor 38.0 net | — | Ben Grogan 84 KO
Matt Hockett 2 KO |
| 2014 | Ben Grogan 19-24 FG | Kaleb Smith 39.8 net | — | Kip Smith 61 KO |
| 2013 | Ben Grogan 10-15 FG | Kaleb Smith 37.4 net
Michael Reichenstein 32.0 net | — | Kip Smith 79 KO
Ben Grogan 1 KO |
| 2012 | Quinn Sharp 25-31 FG | Quinn Sharp 44.8 net | — | Quinn Sharp 82 KO
Bobby Stonebraker 5 KO |
| 2011 | Quinn Sharp 20-23 FG | Quinn Sharp 43.0 net
Michael Reichenstein 49.0 net | — | Quinn Sharp 97 KO |
