| 2026 (in progress) | Kellan McLaughlin 10-14 FG
Brady Stidham 1-1 FG | Pierse Stainton 38.6 net | Trey Wallman 15 snaps | Kellan McLaughlin 39 KO |
| 2025 | Dom Dzioban 17-20 FG | Pierse Stainton 40.0 net | Hudson Powell 9 snaps | Kellan McLaughlin 67 KO |
| 2024 | Dom Dzioban 23-27 FG
Kellan McLaughlin 1-1 FG | Alec Bevelhimer 40.2 net | — | Kellan McLaughlin 56 KO
Carter Holden 4 KO |
| 2023 | Graham Nicholson 26-27 FG | Alec Bevelhimer 44.1 net | — | Graham Nicholson 70 KO
Kellan McLaughlin 6 KO |
| 2022 | Graham Nicholson 18-22 FG | Dom Dzioban 40.3 net
R.Coe 58.0 net | — | Graham Nicholson 35 KO
Henry Beckett 6 KO |
| 2021 | Graham Nicholson 13-17 FG | Dom Dzioban 36.8 net
Alec Bevelhimer 55.0 net | — | Graham Nicholson 54 KO
J.Rolston 4 KO |
| 2020 | Henry Beckett 3-4 FG | Dom Dzioban 42.7 net
Henry Beckett 39.0 net | — | Dom Dzioban 10 KO |
| 2019 | Sam Sloman 25-29 FG | Kyle Kramer 38.3 net
Jacob Swartz 39.0 net | — | Sam Sloman 71 KO
Henry Beckett 1 KO |
| 2018 | Sam Sloman 10-13 FG | Kyle Kramer 38.5 net
Jacob Swartz 27.0 net | — | Sam Sloman 62 KO |
| 2017 | Sam Sloman 12-16 FG | Kyle Kramer 38.8 net | — | Sam Sloman 58 KO |
| 2016 | Nick Dowd 9-11 FG
Sam Sloman 1-3 FG | Justin Martin 35.2 net
Kyle Kramer 38.7 net | — | Sam Sloman 50 KO
Evan Jakubowski 5 KO |
| 2015 | Kaleb Patterson 8-11 FG
Nick Dowd 1-1 FG | Christian Koch 36.2 net | — | Kaleb Patterson 30 KO
Nick Dowd 10 KO |
| 2014 | Kaleb Patterson 9-13 FG | Christian Koch 37.1 net
Christian Kock 36.5 net | — | Kaleb Patterson 55 KO
Christian Koch 1 KO |
| 2013 | Kaleb Patterson 7-10 FG | Zac Murphy 43.1 net
Drew Kummer 27.3 net | — | Mason Krysinski 28 KO |
| 2012 | Kaleb Patterson 15-17 FG | Zac Murphy 38.5 net
Zac Dysert 33.3 net | — | Mason Krysinski 50 KO
Kaleb Patterson 6 KO |
| 2011 | Mason Krysinski 2-6 FG | Zac Murphy 36.8 net
Anthony Kokal 26.6 net | — | Mason Krysinski 45 KO |
