| 2026 (in progress) | Sean O'Haire 8-10 FG | Bryce McFerson 36.5 net
Malik Washington 14.0 net | Luke O'Hare 10 snaps | Daniel Leahy 21 KO
Eli Fulcher 17 KO |
| 2025 | Sean O'Haire 21-24 FG | Bryce McFerson 40.4 net | Ethan Gough 8 snaps | Philip Noyes 38 KO
Ryan Capriotti 17 KO |
| 2024 | Jack Howes 11-16 FG | Bryce McFerson 41.9 net | — | Jack Howes 54 KO
Gavin Marshall 5 KO |
| 2023 | Jack Howes 12-18 FG
Evan Johnson 1-1 FG | Colton Spangler 42.7 net
Brenden Segovia 32.3 net | — | Jack Howes 66 KO
Evan Johnson 1 KO |
| 2022 | Chad Ryland 16-20 FG | Colton Spangler 42.3 net
Anthony Pecorella 37.3 net | — | Chad Ryland 61 KO
A.Laros 2 KO |
| 2021 | Joseph Petrino 11-18 FG
Harrison Beattie 1-1 FG | Anthony Pecorella 37.1 net
Colton Spangler 40.9 net | — | Joseph Petrino 58 KO
Harrison Beattie 4 KO |
| 2020 | Joseph Petrino 4-7 FG | Anthony Pecorella 39.3 net
Colton Spangler 37.9 net | — | Joseph Petrino 20 KO
Anthony Pecorella 1 KO |
| 2019 | Joseph Petrino 2-5 FG | Colton Spangler 39.1 net
Anthony Pecorella 38.4 net | — | Joseph Petrino 50 KO
Paul Inzerillo 5 KO |
| 2018 | Joseph Petrino 12-14 FG | Wade Lees 39.2 net | — | Joseph Petrino 64 KO
Wade Lees 1 KO |
| 2017 | Henry Darmstadter 7-12 FG
Adam Greene 1-2 FG | Wade Lees 37.4 net
DJ Moore 34.0 net | — | Danny Sutton 57 KO
Wade Lees 1 KO |
| 2016 | Adam Greene 8-13 FG
Mike Shinsky 1-1 FG | Wade Lees 38.4 net | — | Danny Sutton 31 KO
Adam Greene 24 KO |
| 2015 | Brad Craddock 8-10 FG
Adam Greene 3-5 FG | Nicolas Pritchard 36.3 net
Brad Craddock 34.2 net | — | Brad Craddock 37 KO
Adam Greene 19 KO |
| 2014 | Brad Craddock 18-19 FG | Nathan Renfro 36.1 net | — | Brad Craddock 64 KO |
| 2013 | Brad Craddock 19-23 FG | Nathan Renfro 38.1 net | — | Brad Craddock 58 KO |
| 2012 | Brad Craddock 10-16 FG
Brendan Magistro 1-1 FG | Nathan Renfro 38.3 net
Brad Craddock 23.0 net | — | Brad Craddock 46 KO |
| 2011 | Nick Ferrara 12-20 FG | Nick Ferrara 38.4 net
Michael Tart 34.0 net | — | Nick Ferrara 47 KO
Michael Tart 4 KO |
