| 2026 (in progress) | Aidan Birr 7-10 FG | Alex Bacchetta 37.0 net | Ronnie Thomas III 6 snaps
Cal Keeler 4 snaps | Aidan Birr 31 KO |
| 2025 | Aidan Birr 25-28 FG | Marshall Nichols 42.0 net | Ronnie Thomas III 10 snaps | Aidan Birr 72 KO |
| 2024 | Aidan Birr 13-19 FG | David Shanahan 37.2 net | — | Aidan Birr 66 KO |
| 2023 | Aidan Birr 14-16 FG
Gavin Stewart 0-3 FG | David Shanahan 39.9 net
B.Travelstead 60.0 net | — | Gavin Stewart 53 KO
C.Davis 8 KO |
| 2022 | Gavin Stewart 12-13 FG
Jude Kelley 2-6 FG | David Shanahan 33.2 net | — | Gavin Stewart 40 KO
Jude Kelley 4 KO |
| 2021 | Brent Cimaglia 11-15 FG
Jude Kelley 0-1 FG | David Shanahan 35.6 net | — | Gavin Stewart 47 KO
J.Richardson 4 KO |
| 2020 | Jude Kelley 1-5 FG
Gavin Stewart 2-3 FG | Pressley Harvin III 44.8 net
Austin Kent 41.3 net | — | Austin Kent 41 KO
Gavin Stewart 3 KO |
| 2019 | Brenton King 3-7 FG
Wesley Wells 0-1 FG | Pressley Harvin III 40.0 net | — | Brenton King 23 KO
Wesley Wells 14 KO |
| 2018 | Wesley Wells 8-8 FG
Brenton King 1-4 FG | Pressley Harvin III 40.8 net | — | Shawn Davis 71 KO
Wesley Wells 5 KO |
| 2017 | Brenton King 5-6 FG
Shawn Davis 2-4 FG | Pressley Harvin III 39.7 net | — | Shawn Davis 27 KO
Brenton King 24 KO |
| 2016 | Harrison Butker 11-13 FG | Ryan Rodwell 38.4 net
Grant Aasen 42.0 net | — | Harrison Butker 65 KO
Shawn Davis 1 KO |
| 2015 | Harrison Butker 7-11 FG | Ryan Rodwell 37.3 net | — | Harrison Butker 60 KO |
| 2014 | Harrison Butker 11-18 FG | Ryan Rodwell 37.6 net | — | Harrison Butker 78 KO |
| 2013 | Harrison Butker 9-13 FG | Sean Poole 41.3 net | — | Harrison Butker 61 KO
David Scully 8 KO |
| 2012 | David Scully 4-8 FG
Chris Tanner 5-6 FG | Sean Poole 38.2 net
Ryan Rodwell 39.7 net | — | David Scully 56 KO
Chris Tanner 15 KO |
| 2011 | Justin Moore 9-12 FG | Sean Poole 38.1 net
Chandler Anderson 37.5 net | — | David Scully 32 KO
Justin Moore 29 KO |
