| 2026 (in progress) | Patrick Durkin 11-12 FG | Alec Clark 42.1 net | Lincoln Anderson 12 snaps | Patrick Durkin 49 KO
Brandon Rabasco 4 KO |
| 2025 | Trey Smack 18-22 FG | Tommy Doman 41.1 net | Rocco Underwood 7 snaps | Trey Smack 61 KO |
| 2024 | Trey Smack 14-17 FG | Jeremy Crawshaw 43.2 net | — | Trey Smack 65 KO |
| 2023 | Trey Smack 17-21 FG
Adam Mihalek 1-3 FG | Jeremy Crawshaw 46.0 net | — | Trey Smack 69 KO
Jeremy Crawshaw 1 KO |
| 2022 | Adam Mihalek 13-19 FG | Jeremy Crawshaw 43.5 net | — | Adam Mihalek 41 KO
Trey Smack 30 KO |
| 2021 | Chris Howard 6-6 FG
Jace Christmann 3-5 FG | Jeremy Crawshaw 39.8 net | — | Jace Christmann 45 KO
Chris Howard 24 KO |
| 2020 | Evan McPherson 15-18 FG
Chris Howard 2-2 FG | Jacob Finn 43.9 net
Kyle Trask 32.0 net | — | Evan McPherson 76 KO
Chris Howard 9 KO |
| 2019 | Evan McPherson 14-16 FG | Tommy Townsend 42.3 net | — | Evan McPherson 71 KO
Chris Howard 3 KO |
| 2018 | Evan McPherson 15-17 FG
Jorge Powell 1-1 FG | Tommy Townsend 42.0 net
Jacob Finn 30.0 net | — | Evan McPherson 72 KO
Jorge Powell 7 KO |
| 2017 | Eddy Pineiro 17-18 FG | Johnny Townsend 41.5 net | — | Eddy Pineiro 50 KO
Luke Ancrum 1 KO |
| 2016 | Eddy Pineiro 18-22 FG | Johnny Townsend 42.0 net | — | Eddy Pineiro 58 KO |
| 2015 | Austin Hardin 5-14 FG
Jorge Powell 2-3 FG | Johnny Townsend 42.7 net | — | Austin Hardin 44 KO
Jorge Powell 18 KO |
| 2014 | Francisco Velez 12-14 FG
Austin Hardin 7-10 FG | Kyle Christy 39.2 net | — | Austin Hardin 64 KO
Brooks Abbott 1 KO |
| 2013 | Austin Hardin 4-12 FG
Francisco Velez 6-8 FG | Johnny Townsend 38.5 net
Kyle Christy 36.8 net | — | Austin Hardin 42 KO |
| 2012 | Caleb Sturgis 23-26 FG
Brad Phillips 0-1 FG | Kyle Christy 43.5 net
Jeff Driskel 15.0 net | — | Caleb Sturgis 58 KO
Brad Phillips 3 KO |
| 2011 | Caleb Sturgis 21-25 FG
Brad Phillips 2-3 FG | Kyle Christy 40.4 net
David Lerner 38.3 net | — | Caleb Sturgis 55 KO
Brad Phillips 15 KO |
