| 2026 (in progress) | Rudy Kessinger 9-12 FG
Donovan Dunmore 0-1 FG | Daniel Hull 39.7 net
Rudy Kessinger 18.0 net | Jack Kautz 11 snaps | Nathan Dibert 37 KO
Adam Samaha 1 KO |
| 2025 | Rudy Kessinger 17-23 FG | Mitchell Tomasek 40.8 net
Rudy Kessinger 36.0 net | Michell Dietzel 5 snaps | Nathan Dibert 61 KO |
| 2024 | Jesus Gomez 18-23 FG
Jess Gmez 2-2 FG | Mitchell Tomasek 39.2 net
Cole Snyder 43.3 net | — | Jesus Gomez 60 KO
C.Allaire 4 KO |
| 2023 | Jesus Gomez 11-15 FG
Kenyon Bowyer 1-1 FG | Mitchell Tomasek 43.7 net | — | Ryan Kingston 31 KO
Kenyon Bowyer 16 KO |
| 2022 | Jesus Gomez 13-16 FG | Mitchell Tomasek 40.0 net
J.Feely 58.0 net | — | Brady Pohl 50 KO
E.Czaplicki 3 KO |
| 2021 | Chad Ryland 17-20 FG | Jake Julien 43.6 net | — | Chad Ryland 60 KO
Jess Gmez 3 KO |
| 2020 | Chad Ryland 11-13 FG | Jake Julien 42.3 net
Chad Ryland 43.0 net | — | Chad Ryland 39 KO |
| 2019 | Chad Ryland 11-16 FG | Jake Julien 39.0 net | — | Chad Ryland 63 KO
Caleb Richwine 4 KO |
| 2018 | Chad Ryland 12-20 FG | Jake Julien 38.1 net | — | Jesse Kelly 58 KO
Chad Ryland 1 KO |
| 2017 | Paulie Fricano 15-21 FG | Jake Julien 39.6 net
Ivan Oraha 30.8 net | — | Jesse Kelly 57 KO
Jake Julien 4 KO |
| 2016 | Paulie Fricano 17-22 FG | Austin Barnes 40.7 net | — | Brendan Renius 73 KO |
| 2015 | Dylan Mulder 11-17 FG
Chase Murdock 0-1 FG | Austin Barnes 40.6 net
Dylan Mulder 33.4 net | — | Brendan Renius 57 KO |
| 2014 | Dylan Mulder 7-10 FG | Owen Dubiel 38.7 net
Austin Barnes 34.0 net | — | Brendan Renius 32 KO
Dylan Mulder 1 KO |
| 2013 | Dylan Mulder 6-11 FG | Austin Barnes 37.1 net
Owen Dubiel 35.1 net | — | Kody Fulkerson 35 KO
Brendan Renius 9 KO |
| 2012 | Dylan Mulder 10-11 FG
Kody Fulkerson 0-1 FG | Jay Karutz 41.3 net | — | Kody Fulkerson 46 KO |
| 2011 | Kody Fulkerson 12-19 FG
N/A 0-1 FG | Jay Karutz 38.0 net | — | Mike Yocum 40 KO
Kody Fulkerson 9 KO |
