| 2026 (in progress) | Elliot Arnold 4-7 FG
Daniel Gerlach 0-1 FG | Damon Greaves 37.9 net | Luke Whiting 8 snaps | Elliot Arnold 18 KO
Cadel Ayala 4 KO |
| 2025 | Alejandro Mata 9-11 FG
Buck Buchanan 0-1 FG | Damon Greaves 38.3 net | Kameron Hawkins 5 snaps | Buck Buchanan 55 KO |
| 2024 | Alejandro Mata 12-14 FG
Jace Feely 0-1 FG | Mark Vassett 38.0 net | — | Daniel Gerlach 29 KO
Alex Stoyanovich 18 KO |
| 2023 | Alejandro Mata 10-12 FG
Jace Feely 4-7 FG | Mark Vassett 41.4 net | — | Jace Feely 43 KO
Cristiano Palazzo 15 KO |
| 2022 | Cole Becker 11-13 FG | Trent Carrizosa 36.9 net
Ashton Logan 36.4 net | — | Cole Becker 43 KO
M.Dapore 4 KO |
| 2021 | Cole Becker 14-20 FG | Josh Watts 38.5 net | — | Cole Becker 49 KO |
| 2020 | Evan Price 5-6 FG
James Stefanou 0-2 FG | Josh Watts 38.0 net | — | Mac Willis 14 KO
Evan Price 7 KO |
| 2019 | James Stefanou 12-17 FG
Evan Price 5-5 FG | Alex Kinney 39.6 net | — | James Stefanou 37 KO
Davis Price 22 KO |
| 2018 | James Stefanou 5-8 FG
Evan Price 4-5 FG | Davis Price 37.2 net
Alex Kinney 40.9 net | — | Davis Price 63 KO |
| 2017 | James Stefanou 17-22 FG | Alex Kinney 41.1 net | — | Davis Price 64 KO
Chris Graham 1 KO |
| 2016 | Chris Graham 10-14 FG
Davis Price 4-6 FG | Alex Kinney 35.0 net | — | Chris Graham 42 KO
Diego Gonzalez 19 KO |
| 2015 | Diego Gonzalez 18-29 FG | Alex Kinney 38.5 net | — | Chris Graham 57 KO
Diego Gonzalez 2 KO |
| 2014 | Will Oliver 16-21 FG | Darragh O'Neill 39.4 net | — | Will Oliver 65 KO
Diego Gonzalez 1 KO |
| 2013 | Will Oliver 17-24 FG | Darragh O'Neill 39.1 net | — | Will Oliver 55 KO
Darragh O'Neill 3 KO |
| 2012 | Will Oliver 6-8 FG | Darragh O'Neill 42.6 net | — | Zach Grossnickle 18 KO
Justin Castor 16 KO |
| 2011 | Will Oliver 11-15 FG | Darragh O'Neill 41.7 net
Mark Brundage 33.0 net | — | Justin Castor 34 KO
Will Oliver 11 KO |
