| 2026 (in progress) | Alex McPherson 6-8 FG | Hudson Kaak 39.4 net | Hudson Powell 6 snaps | Connor Gibbs 28 KO |
| 2025 | Alex McPherson 20-23 FG
Towns McGough 0-1 FG | Hudson Kaak 40.7 net | Reed Hughes 9 snaps | Connor Gibbs 55 KO
Towns McGough 10 KO |
| 2024 | Towns McGough 5-12 FG
Ian Vachon 6-8 FG | Oscar Chapman 40.8 net | — | Towns McGough 61 KO
Ian Vachon 3 KO |
| 2023 | Alex McPherson 13-13 FG | Oscar Chapman 42.0 net | — | Alex McPherson 63 KO |
| 2022 | Anders Carlson 12-17 FG
Alex McPherson 6-7 FG | Oscar Chapman 42.5 net | — | Anders Carlson 43 KO
Evan McGuire 15 KO |
| 2021 | Anders Carlson 14-21 FG
Ben Patton 3-4 FG | Oscar Chapman 42.6 net | — | Anders Carlson 69 KO
Ben Patton 5 KO |
| 2020 | Anders Carlson 18-20 FG | Oscar Chapman 37.9 net
Aidan Marshall 39.1 net | — | Anders Carlson 56 KO |
| 2019 | Anders Carlson 17-24 FG | Arryn Siposs 38.9 net
Bo Nix 26.5 net | — | Anders Carlson 73 KO
Ben Patton 2 KO |
| 2018 | Anders Carlson 15-25 FG
Ian Shannon 0-1 FG | Arryn Siposs 42.2 net
Aidan Marshall 30.0 net | — | Anders Carlson 60 KO
Ian Shannon 9 KO |
| 2017 | Daniel Carlson 21-28 FG | Aidan Marshall 34.1 net
Ian Shannon 38.6 net | — | Daniel Carlson 85 KO
Sage Ledbetter 1 KO |
| 2016 | Daniel Carlson 26-30 FG | Kevin Phillips 39.5 net
Ian Shannon 30.7 net | — | Daniel Carlson 68 KO
Ian Shannon 11 KO |
| 2015 | Daniel Carlson 22-26 FG | Kevin Phillips 37.2 net | — | Daniel Carlson 62 KO
Will Hastings 1 KO |
| 2014 | Daniel Carlson 17-20 FG
Deshazor Everett 0-1 FG | Daniel Carlson 37.5 net
Jimmy Hutchinson 35.1 net | — | Daniel Carlson 76 KO
Alex Kviklys 5 KO |
| 2013 | — | Steven Clark 40.9 net | — | — |
| 2012 | Cody Parkey 11-14 FG | Steven Clark 38.6 net | — | Cody Parkey 41 KO |
| 2011 | Cody Parkey 11-14 FG | Steven Clark 39.8 net
Clint Moseley 39.0 net | — | Cody Parkey 49 KO |
