| 2026 (in progress) | Conor Talty 10-10 FG | Alex Asparuhov 41.3 net | Alex Rozier 8 snaps | Lorcan Quinn 47 KO
Conor Talty 2 KO |
| 2025 | Conor Talty 13-20 FG | Blake Doud 38.8 net | David Bird 4 snaps
Alex Rozier 1 snaps | Conor Talty 65 KO
Reid Schuback 7 KO |
| 2024 | Graham Nicholson 6-8 FG | James Burnip 43.7 net | — | Conor Talty 72 KO
Graham Nicholson 4 KO |
| 2023 | Will Reichard 20-23 FG | James Burnip 42.2 net
Will Reichard 40.2 net | — | Will Reichard 82 KO
Conor Talty 6 KO |
| 2022 | Will Reichard 21-25 FG | James Burnip 39.1 net | — | Will Reichard 86 KO
Jack Martin 5 KO |
| 2021 | Will Reichard 16-20 FG
Jack Martin 1-1 FG | James Burnip 36.8 net | — | Will Reichard 93 KO
Jack Martin 5 KO |
| 2020 | Will Reichard 12-12 FG | Charlie Scott 35.4 net
Sam Johnson 33.2 net | — | Will Reichard 54 KO
Chase Allen 41 KO |
| 2019 | Joseph Bulovas 8-11 FG
Will Reichard 4-7 FG | Ty Perine 36.4 net
Skyler DeLong 32.5 net | — | Joseph Bulovas 71 KO
Will Reichard 30 KO |
| 2018 | Joseph Bulovas 12-16 FG
Austin Jones 1-2 FG | Mike Bernier 35.5 net
Skyler DeLong 34.4 net | — | Joseph Bulovas 108 KO
Austin Jones 1 KO |
| 2017 | Andy Pappanastos 15-19 FG
JK Scott 1-3 FG | JK Scott 40.9 net | — | JK Scott 89 KO |
| 2016 | Adam Griffith 19-26 FG
Andy Pappanastos 1-1 FG | JK Scott 40.3 net | — | Adam Griffith 88 KO
JK Scott 9 KO |
| 2015 | Adam Griffith 21-29 FG | JK Scott 38.4 net | — | Adam Griffith 79 KO |
| 2014 | Adam Griffith 12-19 FG
Gunnar Raborn 2-3 FG | JK Scott 43.3 net | — | Adam Griffith 63 KO
JK Scott 24 KO |
| 2013 | Cade Foster 11-15 FG
Adam Griffith 1-2 FG | Cody Mandell 42.8 net | — | Cade Foster 65 KO
Adam Griffith 14 KO |
| 2012 | Jeremy Shelley 11-11 FG
Cade Foster 4-9 FG | Cody Mandell 41.7 net | — | Cade Foster 89 KO |
| 2011 | Jeremy Shelley 16-20 FG
Cade Foster 2-9 FG | Cody Mandell 37.7 net | — | Cade Foster 66 KO
Jeremy Shelley 7 KO |
